Jingdezhen Heritage · Artwork & Craft

,

How Old Is Archaistic Porcelain — and What Is It Worth?

Archaistic porcelain began at the Yongle imperial kiln 600 years ago. Palace Museum original-versus-copy pairs and eight auction records tell the story.


xuande-ge-copy-bowl

How old is the archaistic porcelain tradition u2014 and what is it worth today? Older than most collectors assume. Jingdezhen‘s true archaistic production began at the Yongle imperial kiln in the early fifteenth century, driven by the antique-loving emperors of the Ming, and it has run almost without interruption for six hundred years. Tang Ying, the celebrated superintendent of the Qing imperial kilns, described the standard it aims at: “In imitating the old, follow its elegance; in imitating the old, never lose its spirit and appearance.” The Palace Museum’s own collections let us check that standard directly u2014 Song originals beside their Ming and Qing copies u2014 and the auction market has priced the tradition at every level from tens of thousands to over a hundred million yuan.

Song dynasty Ge ware bowl with crackled glaze, Palace Museum collection
Song dynasty Ge ware bowl, Palace Museum collection u2014 the original

Where it began: the Yongle imperial kiln

The Palace Museum still holds Yongle-era copies of Song Longquan carved bowls and celadon bowls. Under the Xuande and Chenghua emperors, the imperial kilns reproduced Song Longquan celadon and the wares of Ge, Ru, Guan, Jun and Ding u2014 but with a telling difference: these were acts of homage, not deception. They pursued the spirit and charm of the ancients rather than passing themselves off as old, and most bear their own reign marks in underglaze blue. Because they were made to imperial order, a portion achieved what connoisseurs describe as “so faithful to the ancient that they merge with the true”. The pair below shows how close that could come u2014 a Song Ge ware bowl and its Xuande copy, side by side.

Xuande Ge-type crackle-glazed bowl bearing a Xuande reign mark, Palace Museum collection
Xuande Ge-type bowl with its reign mark on the base u2014 the copy, six centuries on

The Qianlong golden age u2014 and the Republic’s echo

Under the prosperous Kangxi and Qianlong reigns, archaism became a pillar of imperial production. Lan Pu’s Jingdezhen Ta Lu (Record of Jingdezhen Pottery), compiled in the Qing, records the scene: “The wares of our dynasty have reached perfection u2014 workmanship fine and ingenious, colours refined and complete; in following the ancient models, forms and styles change month by month and year by year.” The museum pairs below trace the lineage: a Xuande ewer and its Qianlong re-creation, then a Qianlong enamel vase and a Republic-era copy of the same design.

Xuande blue-and-white ewer with fruit sprays, Palace Museum collection
Xuande blue-and-white ewer with fruit sprays u2014 the original
Qianlong blue-and-white ewer after the Xuande model, with cover
Qianlong blue-and-white ewer after the Xuande model u2014 note the added cover
Qianlong enamel-painted vase with peony design, Palace Museum collection
Qianlong enamel vase with peony design u2014 imitated again in the Republic era

The 1980s revival and an expert’s price tag

The tradition reached its modern chapter in the early 1980s, when the Jingdezhen Ceramics Museum, short of funds, reproduced the Yuan and Ming blue-and-white masterpieces in its own collection. The Palace Museum connoisseur Geng Baochang, in town to grade the holdings, examined the replicas with delight u2014 and priced the very first reproduction meiping at 3,800 yuan, a sum a visiting Japanese tourist paid on the spot. His verdict on the craft, which we tell in full in our report on archaistic porcelain and national treasures: a reproduction that can genuinely deceive a trained connoisseur carries the same value as a national treasure. “Gold in hard times, porcelain in prosperous times” has become the collectors’ maxim; genuine period pieces are scarce and costly, while fine modern work is within reach u2014 and today’s new porcelain, decades and centuries on, becomes the treasured antique of a later age.

What the auction records show

The market has priced the tradition across its whole span. Eight records not commonly seen together:

Piece Price Auction Date
Qianlong flambu00e9-glazed beast-handled zun, after Jun ware RMB 4,945,000 China Guardian 2011-11
Qianlong Ru-type glazed gu vase HK$4,755,000 Sotheby’s London 2014-11
Qianlong Guan-type tubular-handled vase RMB 1,265,000 Beijing Poly 2014-12
Yongzheng yellow-ground blue-and-white ‘one lotus’ dish RMB 18,400,000 Beijing Hanhai 2014-10
Yongzheng blue-and-white fruit-spray meiping HK$14,100,000 Christie’s Hong Kong 2009-12
Yongzheng blue-and-white bamboo-and-banana yuhuchun vase RMB 4,876,000 Sotheby’s Hong Kong 2005-05
Qianlong blue-and-white bamboo-and-banana yuhuchun vase RMB 2,300,000 Beijing Poly 2012-06
Daoguang blue-and-white bamboo-and-banana yuhuchun vases, a pair RMB 2,875,000 Beijing Poly 2014-06

The last three rows make an instructive series: the same bamboo-and-banana vase form, made and sold across three reigns u2014 Yongzheng at 4.9 million, Qianlong at 2.3 million, Daoguang at 2.9 million the pair u2014 a single design carried down the dynasty by its own archaistic impulse. And for contrast, the originals that inspired all of this command their own ladder: a Yongle ‘one lotus’ dish sold for RMB 5,194,000 in 2011, and the Yongle fruit-spray meiping for RMB 138,301,200 u2014 figures we place in context in our report on Yongzheng archaistic porcelain at auction and our overview of what archaistic porcelain is worth.

Qianlong flambu00e9-glazed zun with beast handles, after Jun ware
Qianlong flambu00e9-glazed beast-handled zun after Jun ware u2014 RMB 4,945,000 at China Guardian, 2011
Yongzheng yellow-ground blue-and-white dish with a single lotus spray
Yongzheng yellow-ground ‘one lotus’ dish u2014 RMB 18,400,000 at Beijing Hanhai, 2014
Yongzheng blue-and-white yuhuchun vase with bamboo and banana design
Yongzheng blue-and-white bamboo-and-banana yuhuchun vase u2014 first of the three-reign series

A living discipline

From Yongle homage to Qianlong perfection to Republic echoes and the modern revival, archaistic porcelain is best understood not as imitation but as transmission u2014 each generation of potters learning its ancestors’ craft by rebuilding it. The making standards behind that transmission are set out in the four standards behind a true archaistic reproduction. A piece made to those standards today, bought honestly as what it is, is simply the next ring in a six-hundred-year chain.

Explore Jingdezhen craftsmanship

Jingdezhen Heritage works with workshops that continue these traditions u2014 handmade blue-and-white, famille rose and archaistic pieces fired in Jingdezhen. Browse the collections to see how historic forms and glazes live on in contemporary handmade porcelain.

Contact Jingdezhen Heritage

For enquiries about any piece, custom orders or wholesale, email us at service@jingdezhenheritage.com or message us on WhatsApp.


Enquiries

Ask us about this artwork

For current availability, additional photographs, international shipping or a custom commission, please contact us directly.