Can a well-made reproduction of an ancient porcelain really stand beside a national treasure? According to one of China’s most respected ceramic connoisseurs, it can. Archaistic porcelain u2014 wares made in faithful imitation of earlier classics u2014 pursues accuracy of form, body, glaze and pigment, with decoration and reign marks that echo the original in both appearance and spirit. Some Ming imperial-kiln copies made to the emperor’s own order were described as “so faithful to the ancient that they merge with the true”, and under the prosperous Kangxi and Qianlong reigns the pursuit reached another peak.
The Palace Museum expert’s verdict
In the early 1980s the Jingdezhen Ceramics Museum, short of funds, began reproducing the Yuan and Ming blue-and-white masterpieces in its own collection. By a happy coincidence, Geng Baochang u2014 the celebrated ancient-ceramic authority of the Palace Museum u2014 was in Jingdezhen at that very time grading the museum’s holdings. Examining the newly made replicas, he was delighted and praised them warmly. In his words, archaistic porcelain carries forward China’s great ceramic culture: if a reproduction can genuinely deceive a trained connoisseur, its value is no different from that of a national treasure. That verdict remains the clearest statement of why faithful archaistic work is respected rather than dismissed u2014 a distinction we set out in our overview of archaistic Chinese porcelain and its value.

Gold in hard times, porcelain in prosperous times
“Gold in hard times, porcelain in prosperous times” has become a maxim among Chinese collectors. Fine ceramics is one of the most collectable of the arts, and genuine period pieces survive in such small numbers that they are almost beyond reach. That is why Chen Yejun, head of modern ceramics at the Hubei Collectors’ Association and a long-standing collector, advises enthusiasts to look instead at contemporary art porcelain and at fine modern archaistic pieces u2014 the one category where quality, availability and price still meet.
The craft behind pieces that can fool an expert
The best modern archaistic workshops leave nothing to chance. Some carry out molecular analysis of historic bodies and glazes, then re-engineer the material formulas from scratch; the resulting wares use expensive materials and immense labour, and reach a refinement that can genuinely pass expert inspection. Others combine the techniques of historic imitation with an artist’s own invention, producing wares with a distinctive artistic personality u2014 works of art in their own right. The disciplines involved are examined in detail in the four standards behind a true archaistic reproduction.
And the market has noticed. Collectors have long accepted archaistic porcelain, and as appreciation deepens it attracts more admirers year by year. Today’s carefully made new porcelain, decades and centuries from now, will itself become the heirlooms of a later age.
What the auction records show
Four sales of imperial archaistic wares trace the level the market assigns to faithful imitation:
| Piece | Price | Auction | Date |
|---|---|---|---|
| Qianlong blue-and-white ‘single lotus’ dish, after a Yuan original | HK$726,700 | Sotheby’s New York | 2014-09 |
| Qianlong blue-and-white meiping with fruit sprays | RMB 23,000,000 | Beijing Hanhai | 2011-05 |
| Yongzheng blue-and-white moonflask, after a Yongle model | RMB 6,325,000 | Beijing Jiuge | 2013-06 |
| Yongzheng blue-and-white stemcup with the Eight Treasures, after a Chenghua model | HK$1,224,300 | Beijing Poly | 2014-12 |

For perspective, the ceiling still belongs to period originals: in the same season of 2011 a Yongle blue-and-white fruit-spray meiping, an original rather than an imitation, sold at Sotheby’s Hong Kong for RMB 138,301,200. Our report on Yongzheng archaistic porcelain at auction shows the imperial Song-style archaisms filling the rungs just below it, at 8.1 to 33.6 million yuan each.


A new classic in the making
What Geng Baochang recognised in those 1980s replicas is still the test applied today. An honest archaistic piece u2014 presented as what it is, made with the standards of the imperial kilns u2014 carries real artistic and collectable weight, and need not apologise for being new. Why revival porcelain is not treated as fake in the collecting world is a question of exactly this honesty.
Explore Jingdezhen craftsmanship
Jingdezhen Heritage works with workshops that continue these traditions u2014 handmade blue-and-white, famille rose and archaistic pieces fired in Jingdezhen. Browse the collections to see how historic forms and glazes live on in contemporary handmade porcelain.
Contact Jingdezhen Heritage
For enquiries about any piece, custom orders or wholesale, email us at service@jingdezhenheritage.com or message us on WhatsApp.